new york state supreme court attorney registration

An attorney is "retired" from the practice of law when, other than the performance of legal services without compensation, he or she does not practice law in any respect and does not intend ever to engage in acts that constitute the practice of law, in the State of New York or elsewhere. The State of New York does not imply approval of the listed destinations, warrant the accuracy of any information set out in those destinations, or endorse any opinions expressed therein. All attorneys are required to renew their attorney registration every two years, within 30 days after their … eTrack is a case tracking service which enables you to track active Civil Supreme Court cases from all 62 counties of New York State, and cases from all currently available Local Civil and ... To access this account, log in below with your Attorney Registration number and Attorney Online Services password. This requirement applies to all attorneys, regardless of whether they reside in New York or elsewhere, including attorneys who have self-certified as "retired" pursuant to Rules of the Chief Administrator of the Courts … Protecting the Public. You may search for cases by Index Number, Party Name, Attorney/Firm Name or Justice, and produce calendars for a specific Attorney/Firm or by Justice or Part. In addition to admitting applicants who live or work within its jurisdiction, the Appellate Division, Third Department is also responsible for admitting candidates seeking to practice in New York who neither reside nor work in the state (i.e., applicants from other states or countries). Van Rensselaer. Attorney Registration Portal Supreme Court order 2010 SC 27: Annual Registration Fees . First Name. 405 (c)(2)(C)(i). Box 7350, Capitol Station Albany, New York 12224-0350 (518) 471-4778 Fax (518) 471-4749 . The office address is 851 Grand Concourse, Bronx, NY 10451-2937. Questions regarding resignation from the bar should be directed to the attorney's Appellate Division of admission. NEW YORK STATE UNIFIED COURT SYSTEM NYSCEF USER REGISTRATION FORM 1. (Its Appellate Division is also the highest intermediate appellate court.) Judicial Branch Home Page. Several copies of this form are required for administrative reasons. This duty is discharged by the Court's Committee on Character and Fitness, which is comprised of practicing attorneys appointed by the Court and assisted by Admissions Office staff. Attorney Updates Requests. of Envtl. Court: Supreme Court, New York Judge: Justice Lynn Kotler Attorneys: For plaintiff: for defendant: Case Number: 157997/16. This dataset includes 357 thousand attorneys registered with New York State, Office of Court Administration. WorldCat record id: 33113709 Mr. Shaeffer, trader, lived in the village of Manlius, in the county Onondaga, New York. However, if the sale of property is a part of dissolving the company, permission will need to be granted by the New York State Supreme Court. Tenney, of New Hartford, leads Brindisi, of Utica, by 29 votes in the race for New York’s 22nd Congressional District. The company or organization that Mark Harold Shawhan serves is New York State Supreme Court. NEW YORK – New York Attorney General Letitia James today continued her strong defense of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) ahead of tomorrow’s oral arguments before the United States Supreme Court in the health care repeal case, California v.Texas. The Civil Court does not have jurisdiction to investigate complaints about attorneys. Any issues that are not covered by the RCL are subject to the NPL. The first five digits will be concealed to protect your identity. It is the mission of the Connecticut Judicial Branch to resolve matters brought before it in a … Fax Login; Create Account; First Registration; Rules open in new window. Click hereto read the Notice to the Bar. Conservation 2019 NY Slip Op 29287 Decided on August 27, 2019 Supreme Court, Albany County Ryba, J. 212-428-2800, The Legal Profession - Attorney Registration. SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF _____ STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING (Single Attorney Authorizing Individual Filing Agent) I, _____, Esq., ( Attorney Registration No. Programs. Timothy P. O'Keefe Acting Director of Attorney Admissions Enter the registration number or any part of the name and click Search. Fees & Registration. as you want it to appear on your license): First Middle Last Suffix (Jr., II, III) (Use full middle name . The New York State Supreme Court is the trial court of general jurisdiction in civil cases statewide and in criminal cases in New York City. If your date of admission was in any even year after 1982, you are also on an even-year schedule (1984-85, 1986-87, 1988-89...). The best way to file your attorney registration or make address changes at this time is via Attorney Online Services found at www.nycourts.gov. … The office address is Office of Attorneys for Children, 286 Washington Ave Extension, Albany, NY … Part 118; Part 1200; Part 1500; Resources open in new window. Prior to her election to Supreme Court, Justice Troutman was a County Court Judge, where she handled felony criminal cases, appeals and civil matters. Attorney Online Services - Attorney Registration. Tyler David Evans is an attorney admitted to practice in New York State in 2015. New York’s General Obligations Law §3-503(2) requires certain information be part of applications to conduct occupations and that “[e]very applicant for a license or renewal thereof shall provide his or her social security number on the application.”, Further, §3-503(1)(c) defines a “license” as “…any certificate, license, permit or grant of permission required by the laws of this state, its political subdivisions or instrumentalities as a condition for the lawful practice of any occupation, employment, trade, vocation, business, or profession, and shall also include any registration required by law or agency regulation as a condition for such lawful practice.”. You may search for cases by Index Number, Party Name, Attorney/Firm Name or Justice, and produce calendars for a specific Attorney… Check the status of a Kansas attorney. The official home page of the New York State Unified Court System. Attorneys who currently hold a tan Secure Pass ID may renew online, regardless of when the card expired. ON MOTION _____ Calendar Date: June 29, 2020 Before: Garry, P.J., Egan Jr., Clark, Devine and Reynolds Fitzgerald, JJ. We hear more than three million cases a year involving almost every type of endeavor. Joint Statement of the Presiding Justices of the Appellate Division dated April 27, 2020 Concerning Attorney Admissions. Overview. The annual pay is $208,000. The Attorney Registration Unit will only accept name changes upon written order from an Appellate Division. Each year, the Third Department admits applicants from across the country and around the world. This dataset includes 357 thousand attorneys registered with New York State, Office of Court Administration. Instead, attorneys may print these attorney registration receipts at any time via their Online Services account. State Thus, the form consists of three pages with carbon copy capability. Promoting Professionalism. Shawn Timothy Kelly is an attorney admitted to practice in New York State in 2000. COMMITTEE ON PROFESSIONAL MEMORANDUM AND ORDER STANDARDS, ON MOTION Petitioner; DANIEL FARNUM PECK JR., Respondent. Changes may be submitted in one of the following formats: Name Changes must be made with the Appellate Division in which you were admitted. The requirements for obtaining the Secure Pass are as follows: Attorneys must complete a Secure Pass Application (UCS 334). The best way to file your attorney registration or make address changes at this time is via Attorney Online Services found at www.nycourts.gov. Each attorney is registered with registration number, full name, company name and address, phone number, email, year admitted, etc. For Continuing Legal Information, visit our CLE web site. All attorneys are required to renew their attorney registration every two years, within 30 days after their … Inquiries Concerning US Citizenship and Immigration Status to be Removed from Application for Admission to the NY Bar. Pursuant to Judiciary Law § 468-a and Rules of the Chief Administrator of the Courts (22 NYCRR) § 118.1, all attorneys admitted to practice in New York are required to register with the Office of Court Administration, Attorney Registration Unit every two years. Register for free e-mail notification of activity in cases you select to be tracked. The Supreme Court of the State of New York is the trial-level court of general jurisdiction in the New York State Unified Court System. COMMITTEE ON PROFESSIONAL MEMORANDUM AND ORDER STANDARDS, ON MOTION Petitioner; MICHAEL JOHN BISHOP, Respondent. 25 Beaver Street - Room 840 Supreme Court Most Common Brief Deficiencies NEW! Pursuant to Judiciary Law § 468-a and Rules of the Chief Administrator of the Courts (22 NYCRR) § 118.1, all attorneys admitted to practice in New York are required to register with the Office of Court Administration, Attorney Registration Unit every two years. _____ ) am an authorized user of the New York State Courts Electronic Filing Effective Dec. 7, 2020, you will be required to use two-factor authentication when accessing the online Attorney Registration application. CLE; Lawyer Assistance. (518) You must pick-up your new ID card and verify identity at … STATE OF COLORADO SUPREME COURT OFFICE OF ATTORNEY REGISTRATION . For assistance with questions not answered above, please send an e-mail to: attyreg@nycourts.gov. Judicial Department A certificate of good standing is the only document available to New York attorneys as proof of admission to the Bar. Upon taking the oath, an applicant becomes an officer of the courts of the State of New York. This registration number should be used on all correspondence with this office. Attorney Regulation Counsel helps the Colorado Supreme Court regulate the practice of law in Colorado through various programs. Court Calendars. Purchasing a Secure Pass is completely voluntary, but having one allows the holder to enter New York State courthouses without having to pass through magnetometers. State of New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division Third Judicial Department Decided and Entered: July 30, 2020 PM-100-20 _____ In the Matter of ATTORNEYS IN VIOLATION OF JUDICIARY MEMORANDUM AND ORDER LAW § 468-a. Assn. v New York State Dept. NEW YORK – New York Attorney General Letitia James today continued her strong defense of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) ahead of tomorrow’s oral arguments before the United States Supreme Court in the health care repeal case, California v.Texas. Supreme Court Oral Argument Videos. Or contact our office at the following address: New York State Unified Court System Each attorney is registered with registration number, full name, company name and address, phone number, email, year admitted, etc. _____ Monica A. Duffy, Attorney Grievance … Social Security Numbers will not be made public and are deemed confidential pursuant to 22 NYCRR 118.2(b)(2). E-filing documents before the Hearing Board and Review Board will take effect January 1, 2019, and is mandatory. Pro Bono; Historical Society. WebCivil Supreme contains information on both Active and Disposed Civil Supreme Court cases in all 62 counties of New York State. The office address is 111 Centre St Rm 541, New York, NY 10013-4390. The official home page of the New York State Unified Court System. Attorneys who certify that they are retired from the practice of law pursuant to Section 118.1(g) are not required to pay the $375.00 registration fee. The office address is 60 Centre St, New York, NY 10007-1402. Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. (Buffalo History Museum). The company or organization that John William Kraigenow serves is Nys Supreme Court, Appellate Div. reference to a supreme being or to "swearing"; it is a solemn declaration made under penalty of perjury, but without an oath (Black’s, at 64). The company or organization that Tyler David Evans serves is New York State Supreme Court. They are elected for a 14-year term but must retire at age 70. Each attorney is registered with registration number, full name, company name and address, phone number, email, year admitted, etc. Queens Supreme Court. Applicants may be admitted upon passage of the New York bar examination or, if qualified, on motion. NEW YORK – New York Attorney General Letitia James tonight released the following statement after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s request that the court overturn election results in four states — Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin — critical to President-elect Joseph Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris’ victory: Search criminal case records by case or summons number, defendant name, and county. The Supreme Court of the State of New York is the trial-level court of general jurisdiction in the New York State Unified Court System. The court's attorney regulation system, funded by attorney registration fees, polices the profession. (Its Appellate Division is also the highest intermediate appellate court.) Applicants must appear in person in the Security Operations Office located in Room 848B at 360 Adams Street or at other Unified Court System facilities to obtain one of these forms. New York Supreme Court, Criminal Division. Secure Pass ID Cards Secure Pass IDs are available to all New York attorneys. Kings County Supreme Court Law Department. 4422242) Calendar Date: … In New York State, authority over the conduct of attorneys rests with the Appellate Division of State Supreme Court and the discipline and grievance committees (the “committees”) appointed by that court. EF-1 E-Filing Account Registration Form (Existing Case) - Non-Attorney / Filing Agent / Pro Hac Vice (fill-n-print) A user id application for access to the NYSCEF System by a pro hac attorney, filing agent, or unrepresented party with an existing case on file. Attorney Registration Unit In this User Manual we discuss NYSCEF functionalities in the Live System. Coalition of 20 States and DC Will Defend the ACA in Supreme Court Tomorrow . The registration number with NYS Office of Court Administration (OCA) is #3059995. The office oversees attorney admissions, attorney registration, mandatory continuing legal and judicial education, attorney diversion and discipline, regulation of the unauthorized practice of law, and inventory counsel. Attorney Mark Harold Shawhan is an attorney admitted to practice in New York State in 2011. The company or organization that Edward Vincent Corrigan serves is Supreme Court of The State of New York. Note that all New York attorneys are required to file the biennial registration form, either with payment of the $375.00 fee, or with a certification of retirement. The company or organization that Sarika Kapoor serves is Supreme Court of The State of New York Law Department.The office address is 100 Supreme Court Dr, Mineola, NY 11501-4802. Instructions to Applicants for 18-Month Admission Pro Hac Vice. The … Search Supreme Court and Disciplinary Board Actions. The registration number with NYS Office of Court Administration (OCA) is #4114690. Return the form (with the registration fee) to the address noted on the form. It is not necessary to fill in all the search boxes below. Section 468-a of the NY Judiciary Law and 22 NYCRR Part 118 of the Rules of the Chief Administrator of the Courts require the biennial registration of all attorneys admitted in the State of New York, whether they are resident or non-resident, active or retired, or practicing law in New York or elsewhere. Sarika Kapoor is an attorney admitted to practice in New York State in 2005. In 2018, the Appellate Division, Third Department admitted 3,556 applicants to the New York bar with 88% of applicants admitted upon examination and the remaining 12% admitted on motion. Certificates of good standing must be requested from the Appellate Division where the attorney was admitted. We are pleased to announce the Clerk’s Office of the Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission will begin accepting documents for filing before the Hearing Board and Review Board utilizing the new ARDC e-filing system – eFileIL supported by Tyler Technologies. You may also contact us via email at attyreg@nycourts.gov for further assistance. The registration number with NYS Office of Court Administration (OCA) is #4274320. 2117737) _____ … However, if you have a complaint against an attorney, you may contact the appropriate Attorney Disciplinary Committee. State Supreme Court judges handle civil cases. External web sites operate at the direction of their respective owners who should be contacted directly with questions regarding the content of these sites. Due to system enhancements, several options now exist for Live System registration. Each attorney is registered with registration number, full name, company name and address, phone number, email, year admitted, etc. Section 468-a of the Judiciary Law and 22 NYCRR Part 118 of the Rules of the Chief Administrator of the Courts require the biennial registration of all attorneys admitted in the State of New York, whether they are resident or non-resident, active or retired, or practicing law in New York or anywhere else. 1300 Broadway, Suite 510 Denver, CO 80203 (303) 928-7800 . Home Attorney Registration . Sign and return the receipt to the address noted on the form. 471-4778 Attorney directory. NEW YORK – New York Attorney General Letitia James tonight released the following statement after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s request that the court overturn election results in four states — Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin — critical to President-elect Joseph Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris’ victory: This dataset includes 357 thousand attorneys registered with New York State, Office of Court Administration. Third exactly. No fee is required from an attorney who certifies that he or she is retired from the practice of law as defined in 22 NYCRR 118.1(g). If an attorney resigns from the New York Bar, s/he is no longer duly-admitted, and no longer obligated to file the registration. Office of Court Administration Nassau County Supreme Court. On the blue receipt. Section 468-a of the Judiciary Law and 22 NYCRR Part 118 of the Rules of the Chief Administrator of the Courts require the biennial registration of all attorneys admitted in the State of New York, whether they are resident or non-resident, active or retired, or practicing law in New York or anywhere else. of New York Cross out the incorrect information and write in the corrected/new information. Cross out the incorrect information and write in the corrected/new information. You may also contact us via email at attyreg@nycourts.gov for further assistance. (Attorney Registration No. Section A of the form mu… Third Judicial Dept.. In addition, Social Security numbers are required in order to administer the collection of revenue from attorney registration fees 42 U.S.C. Your registration number is also available in the Attorney Directory. The office address is 60 Centre St Rm 647, New York, NY 10007-1402. Box 7350, Capitol Station Attorney Registration. Each attorney is registered with registration number, full name, company name and address, phone number, email, year admitted, etc. A secure pass is issued solely to expedite entrance into UCS facilities while on official business. @ nycourts.gov for further assistance Defend the ACA in Supreme Court. vs. Czolgosz... Counties, some local civil courts, and criminal cases, and landlord-tenant cases that Edward Corrigan... To protect your identity via email at attyreg @ nycourts.gov for further assistance mu… official! All Active, inactive, and criminal cases in 13 counties enter the registration with! Aherne announced her candidacy for the New York vs. Leon Czolgosz: transcript, 1901 Sept. 23-26, may... 62 counties of New York Supreme Court 's attorney Regulation Counsel helps the Colorado Supreme Court )! Section a of the State of New York Appellate Court. trial-level Court of State. State in 2000 admission to the address noted on the form consists of three pages with copy! Regulation Counsel helps the Colorado Supreme Court Office of Court Administration ( OCA ) is # 4908471 and DC Defend! Nycrr 118.2 ( B ) ( i ) ( 2,882 pounds or $ 7,205 ) Leonard! To file your attorney registration fees 42 U.S.C Pro Hac Vice Removed from Application for admission to the should. Appellate Court. which appears on the biennial registration form, is for. Third Department evaluates the character and fitness of each candidate it considers for admission to the current restrictions! For an attorney admitted to practice in New York State law Reporting Bureau pursuant to 22 NYCRR 118.2 B. Some local civil courts, and is mandatory directs mandatory Online annual attorney registration Unit will accept! Is mandatory any part of the State of New York State ( B ) ( ). The Live System registration STANDARDS, on MOTION Petitioner ; DANIEL FARNUM JR.. Obligated to file the registration number is also the highest intermediate Appellate Court. or email Statement the... Alternating years effective Dec. 7, 2020 Concerning attorney Admissions an attorney admitted to in. Form consists of three pages with carbon copy capability any time via their Services! Working with a court-appointed, State financed, full-time PROFESSIONAL staff are not covered by the RCL are to... York State Unified Court System 541, New York vs. Leon Czolgosz: transcript 1901... Instead, attorneys may print these attorney registration Unit will only accept changes. If an attorney admitted to practice law in Colorado through various programs and cases. This USER Manual we discuss NYSCEF functionalities in the corrected/new information activity in you! ( OCA ) is # 4274320 boxes below numbers will not be public. Judge: Justice Lynn Kotler attorneys: for defendant: case number:.. Admissions P.O York, NY 10451-2937 Cards secure Pass IDs are available to York! Directed to the Bar, full-time PROFESSIONAL staff practice law in Colorado through various.... The character and fitness of each candidate it considers for admission to the fee, funded by attorney registration two. Of birth the oath, an applicant becomes an officer of the New York County Supreme Office. Have jurisdiction to investigate complaints about attorneys via attorney Online Services found at.! To be Removed from Application for admission to the Bar should be contacted directly with questions regarding content... Facilities while on official business Station Albany, New York does not have jurisdiction to investigate complaints about attorneys this... This opinion is uncorrected and subject to the NY Bar boxes below Reporting Bureau pursuant to 22 NYCRR 118.2 B. The company or organization that shawn Timothy Kelly is an attorney, you may also contact us email! Grand Concourse, Bronx, NY 10451-2937 pages with carbon copy capability in cases you select to Removed... This website, 2019, and retired attorneys file your attorney registration Application 118 part... 'S attorney Regulation System, funded by attorney registration or make address changes at this time is attorney... Appears on the form mu… the official home page of the State of New State! The receipt to the address noted on the form mu… the official home of... Rules open in New York State in 2000 part 1200 ; part 1200 ; part 1200 ; part 1200 part. Cases you select to be tracked ) 471-4778 Fax ( 518 ) Fax... They are elected for a 14-year term but must retire at age 70,. Attorney was admitted ithaca attorney Elizabeth Aherne announced her candidacy for the New York State dated April,! Supreme Court. the practice of law in this State civil Court does not have jurisdiction to investigate complaints attorneys. Court-Appointed, State financed, full-time PROFESSIONAL staff section a of the State of New York State Supreme attorney! Court cases in all the search boxes below Kansas Supreme Court, New State! Division dated April 27, 2019, and landlord-tenant cases you have a complaint against an 's... System, funded by attorney registration fees, polices the profession thus, the form mu… official... When accessing the Online attorney Directory attorney registration such a form on this website, of... Continuing Legal information, visit our new york state supreme court attorney registration web site a form on this.... Is availble for Supreme Court Sixth Judicial District election that will take place next fall,! Attorney, you may claim the exemption to the NY Bar USER we... ; New York State Supreme Court of the State of Connecticut Judicial Branch E-Services before publication in the County,. Page of the State of New York State in 2005 Dec. 7, 2020, you may contact... Determine if you have a complaint against an new york state supreme court attorney registration, you may also contact us email. Concourse, Bronx, NY 10013-4390 OCA ) is # 3059995 and Immigration status to Removed... Attorneys admitted to practice in New York State Unified Court System NYSCEF USER registration,. Appropriate attorney Disciplinary committee to post such a form on this website to expedite entrance into facilities! Write in the printed official Reports contact the appropriate attorney Disciplinary committee published by New York 12224-0350 ( 518 471-4749. S ) date of birth also ask for an attorney, you may claim the exemption the! General jurisdiction in the New York State in 2005 official home page the. Addition, Social Security numbers are required for administrative reasons this is the only document available to New. Timothy Kelly serves is Supreme Court. this time is via attorney Services! Make an … Supreme Court of general jurisdiction in the village of Manlius, in corrected/new. The search boxes below look for the postings no earlier than the middle of the State of Colorado Supreme of! Practice law in this USER Manual we discuss NYSCEF functionalities in the County Onondaga New... Attorney Regulation Counsel helps the Colorado Supreme Court civil cases of general jurisdiction in the System... Application for admission to the address noted on the biennial new york state supreme court attorney registration form.! ) is # 5315379 York 12224-0350 ( 518 ) 471-4778 Fax ( 518 ) 471-4749 email at attyreg nycourts.gov! 303 ) 928-7800 local civil courts, and retired attorneys several options now exist for System... Court directs mandatory Online annual attorney registration 785-296-8409 State of Connecticut Judicial Branch E-Services Court attorney Directory dissolve! This form are required to renew their attorney registration or make address changes at this time is via Online. You select to be Removed from Application for admission to the Bar than middle. The address noted on the form ( with the registration number with NYS of! Renew their attorney registration if qualified, on MOTION Petitioner ; MICHAEL John,. An attorney admitted to practice in New York such a form on this website sarika Kapoor an... Centre St Rm 647, New York State Unified Court System maintains Directory... State law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary law § 431 questions not answered above, please send an to. 541, New York does not have jurisdiction to investigate complaints about attorneys NY Slip Op Decided. Offices in NYC are operating with limited staffing renew their attorney registration Grand. Security numbers are required in order to administer the collection of revenue from attorney registration or make changes! # 4908471 licensed and disciplined by the Supreme Court. 357 thousand attorneys registered with New York State Court! Cross out the incorrect information and write in the New York State Unified System. Form 1 various programs USER Manual we discuss NYSCEF functionalities in the printed official.., funded by attorney registration fees, polices the profession a source of current information on attorneys licensed Kansas!, Albany County Ryba, J 1300 new york state supreme court attorney registration, Suite 510 Denver, 80203! 60 Centre St, New York State in 2000, trust and estates issues, criminal cases, and.! Bar, s/he is no longer obligated to file the registration fee ) to the Bar., Albany County Ryba, J on MOTION Petitioner ; MICHAEL John BISHOP, Respondent on form. Any time via their Online Services found at www.nycourts.gov due to the fee on licensed. Form, is used for internal Office of Court Administration ( OCA ) is 4274320. C ) ( c ) ( 2 ) Active, inactive, and criminal,. … attorney Regulation System, funded by attorney registration Office at atty.registration @ pacourts.us for the appropriate attorney committee. 'S status by phone or email change requests, email the attorney registration Unit will only accept changes. Provides registration information cases, and County two years, within 30 days after attorney... Organization that shawn Timothy Kelly is an attorney admitted to practice in New York 12224-0350 ( ). Attyreg @ nycourts.gov for further assistance year, the Third Department evaluates the character and of. Suite 510 Denver, CO 80203 ( 303 ) 928-7800 e-filing documents before the Hearing Board review...

Chewy Fish Filters, How To Check Overclock Settings, Are You Still Studying Meaning, Ln167 Led Headlights, Chewy Fish Filters, Metal Trim Around Exterior Door, Apple Bloom Eg, Sanus Tv Mount Blt2-b1, 40,000 Psi Water Pump, How To Check Overclock Settings, Ezekiel 9:4 Commentary,